FREE SHIPPING $45+ Use Code: FREESHIP45 | Details

Blessings in Disguise - Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries - Series - Book 1

Sit back and enjoy a vacation for your soul with Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries. This uplifting, fascinating, and inspiring series whisks you away to the scenic hillside of Ohio’s Amish country and draws you into the excitement as Cheryl and her Amish friend, Naomi, work together to solve highly intriguing mysteries.

Free Gifts with Purchase ($30 value)! A gold-tone filigree heart necklace and sturdy tote FREE with Book 1 purchase or series join.

Grouped product items
Product Name Qty
Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries - Join the Series
BEST DEAL! Subscribe & save $2 per book
$15.95 per book. Series starts with book 1, Blessings in Disguise. No obligation—cancel anytime
Special Price $15.95 Regular Price $17.95
Blessings in Disguise - Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries - Book 1 - HARDCOVER

Product Description

Blessings in Disguise is the first book in the Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries fiction series.

As Cheryl takes inventory of the Swiss Miss gift shop stock and acclimates herself to her new surroundings amid petting zoos and corn mazes, she notices something peculiar happening. Some of the items that customers want to purchase from her store are not listed in her inventory.

Where are these quality products coming from? Is it, as Cheryl’s new friend Naomi Miller believes, that someone is sending her an anonymous blessing? If so, what is she to make of the menacing notes that keep surfacing, which warn her to “take care”… 

Meet the Characters

Naomi Miller
Cheryl’s newfound friend, 40-year-old Naomi Miller, supplies homemade jams, jellies, baked goods, and fudge for the Swiss Miss gift shop to supplement her family’s income. Married to Seth, Naomi has three stepchildren and three children of her own.

Seth Miller
Naomi’s husband, Seth, is a hard worker and good provider for his family. While he appears to be standoffish and serious, he is in fact full of wit and entrepreneurial ideas. He feels responsible for the fact that his daughter, Sarah, eloped with an “Englisher”.

Levi Miller
Seth Miller’s eldest son Levi, spends most of his time tending to the horses after being rejected by a young woman he grew up believing he would someday marry. Levi insists he has forsaken marriage…until he meets Cheryl Cooper. Still, a romantic relationship with an “Englisher” could never work. Or…could it?

Ben and Reuben Vogel
Years ago, Ben was shunned by the Amish (including his brother, Reuben) when he left the church. That’s why Ben and Reuben never speak to each other. They just meet at the Swiss Miss gift shop every other day to play checkers in silence.


Additional Information

Continuity Series Details

FOR PRINT SERIES FORMAT ONLY:  When you click the Place Order button you are authorizing Guideposts to charge your credit card for the intro shipment and all future shipments.  You should receive your first shipment within 3-4 weeks of ordering.  Then, unless you cancel, about every 4 to 6 weeks you will automatically receive a new book for only $15.95, plus $3.99 shipping, and sales tax where applicable. If the credit card is declined for any shipment, Guideposts will mail an invoice when the book is shipped.  If you are not completely satisfied, you may return any shipment within 30 days and owe nothing. We will refund (or credit your credit card) the value of the merchandise you return. There is no minimum number of books to purchase and you may cancel at any time by calling customer service at 1-800-932-2145, Monday - Friday, 8 am to 6 pm EST or by visiting and logging into your account.


As a subscriber you'll save $2 OFF each book in the series and enjoy your Free Gifts with your first shipment. You will receive a new book every 4-6 weeks. There's no obligation. You can cancel your subscription any time online or by phone. And if you ever receive a book you don't like, return it for a full refund of the purchase price--no questions asked.

We’ll include a special surprise for you along with one of the series shipments!